My Thoughts on Stuff I Should Stay Away From: Webcomics.com
Okay folks, I am sorry that I am about to talk about something that almost no one but other folks with webcomics will care about, and I know that I promised that there was going to be a movie review, (and there will be tomorrow, it is already written,) but I just had to get a couple of things off my chest.
As you may or may not know, webcomics.com, a community website set up by the authors of the wonderfully helpful book “How To Make Webcomics” have decided to make their site a pay site.
Now honestly, I could have cared less. I find it slightly hypocritical given their whole business model is the content is free, you buy the extras, and that in a sense the website is an extension of the book which I did purchase, but I digress. They can do whatever they want, and for my part I wont be joining. (I also wont join Costco, in the eternal words of my main man, Groucho Marx, “I’d never belong to a club that would have me for a member”)
“So what did piss you off?” you may ask. Well it a statement by Brad Guigar, the creator of Evil Inc [not linked on purpose] and the editor and chief of the webcomics.com site. The quote is this:
“It’s an inexpensive buy-in that almost any webcartoonist can afford. It has an added benefit of keeping out people who may not be as serious about webcomics. It naturally weeds out comments from people who may be passing through, and results in distilling comments to those from people who are committed to improving their comics.”
So here is the thing, $30 bucks actually is an expense that, all things considered, I can not afford. I am a full time college student, and a hairdresser who is struggling to make ends meet. If it wasn’t for my student loans and the help of my wonderful girlfriend and family, I don’t know what I would do.
Now is this to say that I NEVER get an extra $30 bucks? No, of course not, but that money could be better spent on, oh I don’t know, advertising, or put in a pool to hopefully take some more classes in the skills that I am constantly refining to produce better and better comics. This year alone, I have spent a considerable deal on drawing classes, not to mention the creative writing workshops and what not.
All in all, I give about 50 hours a week to my comic, and to imply that I am not “serious” about my comic is flat out offensive. I was unaware that to be serious I need to be more interested in “work shopping my ads” (a real thing) then producing top quality work, which at the end of the day is really what keep folks reading a comic.
Lastly, and this is a low blow, but I recently heard Guigar (on his Fox Business interview) say that he still has a day job. Now, I too have a day job, that’s cool, but I am not presenting myself as a pro (and the definition of a professional is someone who makes the majority of there income from something) and asking people to pay for my advice!
So what does all this mean, what is the solution? Well there isn’t one. I probably wont read Evil inc. anymore, but truthfully I always found it contrite, like it was begging to be a hit, but there is no way I will stop reading his partner Dave Kellett’s strip Sheldon, that shit is great. For me personally, the fall out is that I just got to see someone I viewed as a great spokesmen of the community, lost my respect because of a perceived cash grab. I will now just sit back and see who takes his place (Maybe it will be you!!!).
Also, for 15 bucks a year, I will stroke your ego, and give you critism on your webcomic, it’s a real bargin!! (hell I’ll even reopen my forum so you can discuss stuff amongst yourselves.)
John K.




i obviously do not have a webcomic but i have to agree paying 30 bucks is retarded. i’m shocked that they are now charging considering how many ppl are out of work and struggling to make ends meet!
I think there is a difference between offering a free webcomic and offering free advice. I don’t begrudge webcomics.com from becoming a subscription service at all. The issue is will there be enough seasoned cartoonists and newbie cartoonists to continue to make it worthwhile.
Most comic collectives focus too much on promoting their favorite cartoons or even on listing a bunch of cartoons. The thing that webcomics did well that other collectives need to emulate is the interaction level of the cartoonists.
Create opportunities for providing information and finding the information will be key if any of them are serious about filling the void.
@bearman: Please don’t think that I have any problem with them charging to use their site, that is totally their right, and I wish them nothing but success.
My gripe is more on the idea that if I don’t join I am not serious. I find this very offensive. I work my tail off on my comic, and I think that it is irresponsible for someone to claim that their product is the barometer of who is serious and who isn’t.
But them charging… go for it. Hell, if I could get anyone to pay to read my comic, I’d charge.
Think of it this way: if the articles and advice they provide is really all that valuable, within ten minutes of it being posted on the internet it’ll be copypasted onto a website we can view for free. Besides, after buying the book and trying desperately to keep paying attention to the website, I think Brad would have to try really really hard to make that website worth a subscription. I too am serious about my webcomic, and would rather spend my time improving the comic’s art and writing, rather than reading articles about the terrors of the U.S postal service.
I think Guigar’s either a successful hobbyist or a failing professional. Really don’t feel his comic backs up his claims of being one of the leading names in webcomics, just one of the most vocal and shameless.
Either way, I’m not paying $30 for his advice on how to sell sell sell (out?)
I always regarded webcomics.com as a place for comic creators to go to learn new things and meet other like-minded peers. I don’t wanna pay $30 a year just for some tutorials that I can find if I Google hard enough. I’ve visited the site less and less in the last six months, and now it seems like I’ll never get to visit it at all anymore. I don’t knock the guys for making it a subscription-only venture, I just don’t see it being worth $30 sight-unseen.